- Key Focus Areas
- Enquiries & Complaints
- Human Rights
- The Treaty
- Race Relations
- Disabled People
- International & UN
- Office of Human Rights Proceedings
- More work to be done by New Zealand to fully realise the rights of the disabled
- Fair travel for support workers removes an existing injustice
- #RainbowLaces campaign against homophobia in football kicking off this weekend
- Board Members Wanted for Auckland Refugee Council
- Race Relation Commissioner Dame Susan Devoy’s opening speech at the New Zealand Diversity Forum, 24 August.
- MORE NEWS
- HRC praises Auckland mum for speaking out about humiliating treatment
- Commissioner Jackie Blue’s address ‘Women’s rights are human rights’ to BPW Franklin
- Human Rights Commission condemns violent hate attack on gay Wellingtonians
- Human Rights Commission welcomes investment in Christchurch’s children
- Woman censured for using Kia ora should contact the Commission
- Dame Susan Devoy’s speech to open Islam Awareness Week: 18 August 2014
- The Right To Work: Young New Zealanders in South Auckland
- Islam Awareness Week for all Kiwis – Human Rights Commission
- We have a lot of work to do – Race Relations Commissioner
- Human Rights Commission proud to back peace call from Kiwi interfaith leaders
- Disabled people deserve better health and education
- Access to buildings is a human right, says monitoring group
- Human Rights Commission urges politicians to stick to the major issues
- Human Rights Commission congratulates YWCA Equal Pay Award Recipients
- Deaf Maori experience on show in Wellington
- ALL NEWS
Landmark gender discrimination ruling for OHRP
A Wellington High Court Judge and two members of the Human Rights Review Tribunal have ruled against a fishing company in a landmark case involving gender discrimination.
The case involved two knife operator positions at Talleys’ fish processing plant at Motueka. Both positions involved use of a knife at speed in cold and wet conditions. The practice at the plant was to assign lower paid fish trimmer roles to women, reserving the higher paid fish filleting roles for men.
The High Court judgment this week found the jobs were “substantially similar” and that Talleys had discriminated against the complainant Caitlin Lewis by paying her less money than filleters for her work.
The judgment stated: “The reason she received less money was because she was made a trimmer, and the reason she was made a trimmer was because she was a woman.”
The Assistant Director of the Office of Human Rights Proceedings Catherine Rodgers who acted for Ms Lewis said,
“This is a landmark case as the legal/threshold question of what ‘substantially similar’ means for the purpose of comparing jobs to determine whether they warrant equal pay has not been tested in the courts before”.
Ms Rodgers said, “The High Court said the words substantially similar should be assessed by looking at the core aspects of jobs rather than differences in detail. The view of employers about the value of different jobs was not determinative, rather an objective assessment was required”.
The High Court also found in favour of a complaint of victimisation by Ms Lewis’ partner Brett Edwards who was refused a job at Talleys after Ms Lewis complained to the Human Rights Commission.
Talleys has agreed to pay compensation for lost income and injury to feelings to Ms Lewis and Mr Edwards. As part of the settlement Talleys also agreed to undertake human rights training for its managers and to implement an equal employment opportunity policy.
Equal Employment Opportunities Commissioner Dr Judy Mc Gregor said,
“The decision is significant. It means that employers should not be segregating women into work that is substantially similar to work being undertaken by men but with less money. This disadvantages women and perpetuates pay inequity”.
She added: “The decision also upholds the rights of a female complainant to legitimately reject lower pay for work in these circumstances – good on her”.
For media inquiries contact Carolyne Jurriaans on 09) 375 8616 or Gilbert Wong on 09) 306 2660.